Alright, I’m going to lay it down hard. We
recently just started The Stranger by
Albert Camus and I am loving it. So, my initial reactions to the first chapter
of the book are a bit weird so just bear with me. Camus opens up the novel with
the line “Maman died today. Or yesterday maybe, I don’t know.” This was both
shocking yet disturbingly funny to me. Yes funny, I laughed a little. But what
I found a bit humorous was that he wasn’t sure which day his mother had died;
just disputing it in his head which one it was: today or yesterday. But after
that first bout of giggles, it got a bit disturbing at how unfazed this man was
by his Maman’s death. Something else that I found really funny was when he
started smoking during his mom’s vigil. Thinking about it, it’s not really
funny at all—kind of disrespectful if you will. But he thought “it didn’t
matter.” (8). I guess his lack of emotion mixed with a bit of stunned
disbelief is why I found it so funny. Or maybe I just have a really bizarre
sense of humor, who knows.
Reading further into chapter, I noticed
how little Meursault seemed affected by the death of his mother. He was just focused
on other mundane things going on around him.
I mean, the death of a parent is a pretty big deal, but our main
character here just kind of swept it under the rug. I feel like he treated the vigil
and funeral as an obligation. And if he didn’t do it, then he would be looked
down upon or judged or something. So basically, to this ordinary fella, his mother’s
funeral was kind of like jury duty.
At
this point in the book, I’m not sure if Meursault's detachment is a personality trait
or if he just feels very little about this event. But I’m kind of getting the
vibe that this may just be the type of person he is. I think that he is aware
that his reaction to this death is an abnormal one; that he is supposed to be
sad. I thought of this because Camus writes:
“We put the cover on, but I’m supposed to
unscrew the casket so you can see her.”
He was moving toward the casket when I stopped
him.
He said, “You don’t want to?” I answered, “No.”
He was quiet, and I was
embarrassed because I felt I shouldn’t have
said that.
Meursault recognizes that what he said might not have
been the right thing to say in this situation. But a couple of lines later, the
caretaker replies “I understand”. I interpreted this as if the caretaker
thought seeing his mother dead and never to return again would make him more
upset (if he is upset at all). But I think that Meursault just wanted to
get quickly finish the funeral so he could go back to his life before it.
Although, in class we also discussed that
his lack of emotion to this may just be a part of his grievance process. It’s
only the first chapter, so we have no background idea on how this character reacts
emotionally in other situations. I think it may be a possibility that this may
be his process of accepting that his mother is dead. For instance,
he says:
But he probably will day after tomorrow,
when he sees I’m in mourning. For now, it’s almost as if Maman weren’t dead. After
the funeral, though, the case will be closed, and everything will have a more
official feel to it. (3)
Here, Meursault states that Maman dying hasn’t really
sunk in yet. And it seems as if he is expecting himself to mourn later on,
after the funeral is done and over with. But what I wonder is if it would
really make a difference in his life. In the chapter he talks about how he
never really saw his Maman because the trip was too long and he didn’t have
time for it. So he was already accustomed to not seeing Maman regularly; how
would it change with the knowledge that she is now dead?
I too am really enjoying The Stranger and I agree that the way Mersault seems so detached is a little erie. I have noticed a lot of similarities between The Stranger and other books we read this semester. The opening line “Maman died today.” reminds me of the opening of The Metamorphosis in its shocking revelation. I have also noticed when Albert Camus tries to emulate Hemingway’s writing style. I’m not sure if I like it because is comes off a little forced and awkward. “I like milk in my coffee, so I said yes…” I feel like he is trying to be like Hemingway here but I’m not convinced. Overall I like this novel and I’m excited to see what the rest of The Stranger holds.
ReplyDeleteI agree that there are similarities between Camus and Hemingway, which is probably due to the fact that Hemingway inspired a lot of other writers to write in the way that he did. But you also have to keep in mind that Camus is his own writer. I think he is definitely inspired by Hemingway's work but we can't exactly critique it by saying "he was trying to be Hemingway and failed" because Camus's has his own writing style that has to/is standing out in his work(s).
DeleteYou bring up a good point. If he was already accustomed to not seeing his mother regularly, shouldn't his life stay pretty much the same? I wouldn't think so because I feel like knowing you have a mother and not really talking to her is different than knowing that you can't talk to your mother anymore, that you lost your chance. But, his being accustomed to being without his mother would provide an explanation for his peculiar behavior. It's like his mother and the nursing home: "He was used to it".
ReplyDeleteI don't think he reacts the way he does because he doesn't care about his mother or finds it similar to jury duty. I do agree that he's detached, though. His detachment as we've seen so far just means that he doesn't show his emotions. I don't necessarily think that he's unaware of the fact that she's died, and we just have to wait for it to hit him. When he contemplates smoking at his mother's wake, I took his "it doesn't matter" not as a form of disrespect, but as him realizing that she is in fact dead, and won't scold him. Or he just finds it a petty concern. He seems to love his mother, but I don't think he's going to go into grief as we know it any time soon.
ReplyDeleteWhen I first began The Stranger, I thought the book was hilarious. I found myself laughing at parts that were not intended to funny. Especially in the beginning, when Meursalt was just not reacting to his mother's death and people were kind of offended by this emotional detachment, my enjoyment of the story seemed a little peculiar. Yet, after reading the later chapters, I find myself drifting from Meursalt's disconnected narration style.His inability to care has led him to make some decisions that I disagree with and it's a little bit harder to find humor in murder. Yet, this novel is still fascinating and I'm looking forward to what happens next.
ReplyDeleteI agree with you, for the most part. However, I think that his mother actually meant more to him than he is letting on. He does not want to see her dead. Might this suggest denial?
ReplyDeleteI agree with you that his mom did mean a lot more to him than he tells us. Especially with the constant mentions of his mom here and there at random spots in the book. For instance, he thought about his mom when he heard Salamano crying in his room. And he didn't really know why he thought of her in that moment, which I found really interesting.
DeleteHe also mentions very briefly during the procession that he would be enjoying the weather if it weren't for his mother. That could mean simply that he's occupied by the funeral and so not free to walk around in the sunlight, but when I read it, I assumed that he meant that he couldn't be happy because of her death. As the story continues, though, that it seems more and more likely there was no emotion to be read into that passage.
DeleteI think that Mr. Mersault doesn't necessarily tell us all that he feels. But, there is still a chance that he is just so detached that he doesn't feel much. I think he definitely feels something for his mother, because he reminisces about her in a way that he wouldn't if she were alive. Mersault isn't an extremely reliable narrator, so we need more than just his point of view to properly understand his feelings about his mother's death.
ReplyDeleteI also think Mersault is detached, but much more than we thought in the beginning of the book. After all, the magistrate asks him how he feels about the murder, and Meursault says he is "annoyed" more than anything else. But there's also this gap between Mersault's inner borderline nihilism and what he says out loud, that makes him sound worse than he is. For example, the magistrate asks Meursault if he loves Maman, to which he replies "Yes, the same as anyone else" which makes the typewriter freak out. Meursault means he loves his mother as much as anoyone loves theirs, but I think they interpret it to mean he loves his mother as much as any casual friend. This gap reminds me of Gregor during the beginning of The Metamorphosis, when he's still trying to talk.
ReplyDeleteDuring the discussion in class I was wondering that maybe Meursault is avoiding his mother's death. People react to stress in different ways, with some of these reactions seeming inappropriate considering the circumstance. If Meursault really is grieving through avoidance, is it fair to judge him poorly for acting differently? Having gotten further along in the book, I now wonder if his trial is meant to allude to how non-conformity brings about punishment. Meursault's behavior is natural to himself but not to the people around him in court, who perceive his way of responding to the world as faults in his character. Meursault did kill a man but his actions during and after the funeral are being scrutinized and used against him.
ReplyDelete